FlashcardsNotesPractice QuestionsMy ProgressFriendsPast PapersLog in
FlashcardsNotesPractice QuestionsMy ProgressFriendsPast PapersLog in

AcePE is an independent student-made resource. Not affiliated with or endorsed by AQA.

About this siteSend feedbackPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service

← Ethics

Ethics

05

Commercialisation & the Media

The golden triangle

Key terms

Commercialisation
The treating of sport as a commodity, with the market driving decisions.
Sponsorship
The provision of funds or support in return for a commercial return.
Golden triangle
The relationship between sport, commercialisation and the media, where each point depends on and profits from the other two. The media uses sport to attract audiences to sell to advertisers, businesses use the media to advertise and pay sport directly, and sport needs media exposure to attract sponsorship.

Side by side

Commercialisation brings

Advantages
Increased income and promotion, increased sponsorship, better organised and funded events, and improved facilities
Disadvantages
Sensationalised reporting; media and sponsors dictating kick-off times and changing the nature of a sport; minority sports losing out; excessive demands on performers; and pressure to win or to maintain lucrative contracts
For elite sportAdvantagesDisadvantages
Commercialisation bringsIncreased income and promotion, increased sponsorship, better organised and funded events, and improved facilitiesSensationalised reporting; media and sponsors dictating kick-off times and changing the nature of a sport; minority sports losing out; excessive demands on performers; and pressure to win or to maintain lucrative contracts

Media coverage and ring-fencing

Key terms

Ring-fenced
Events that must be available on free-to-air television.
Category A
Events that must have live free-to-air coverage, such as the FA Cup Final and the World Cup Finals.
Category B
Events that can be pay-per-view provided a highlights package is free-to-air, such as Test cricket and the Open Golf.

Television is the best medium for sport, because it transmits live images to huge audiences instantly. Satellite television such as Sky Sports and BT Sport charges subscribers for access, as BT's purchase of Setanta showed.

The list of ring-fenced events has shrunk, because satellite channels offer riches sporting authorities cannot ignore. England home Test cricket moved from Category A to Category B from 2006. The arguments for continuing to ring-fence are reaching the widest range of viewers, avoiding restricting coverage to those who can pay, increasing geographical access, and protecting sporting heritage such as the Olympics and Wimbledon.

The growth of media money

Premier League television rights income has grown enormously across successive deals since the early 1990s.

What broadcasters want is fairly consistent: a high level of skill, something that looks good on screen, rules simple enough to follow without explanation, a format that fits a short slot, and recognisable personalities to build the coverage around. Sports without those qualities, badminton and table tennis among them, get less airtime, which brings less commercial interest, which keeps them closer to amateur, which in turn keeps the airtime away. It is a vicious circle.

Side by side

For sport

Advantages
Increases the profile of a sport and its performers; increases participation; creates more media-friendly variations of a sport such as Twenty20 cricket; generates higher income and commercial opportunities; and drives up standards of performance and behaviour
Disadvantages
NGBs and performers lose control to television companies and sponsors; media control locations, kick-off times and playing seasons; too much sport on television can lead to boredom; inequalities of coverage disadvantage minority sports; and over-sensationalised coverage can encourage a win-at-all-costs attitude
Media coverageAdvantagesDisadvantages
For sportIncreases the profile of a sport and its performers; increases participation; creates more media-friendly variations of a sport such as Twenty20 cricket; generates higher income and commercial opportunities; and drives up standards of performance and behaviourNGBs and performers lose control to television companies and sponsors; media control locations, kick-off times and playing seasons; too much sport on television can lead to boredom; inequalities of coverage disadvantage minority sports; and over-sensationalised coverage can encourage a win-at-all-costs attitude

Why sport attracts business

Sport is attractive to business because it offers extensive media coverage, large audiences, a professional high-profile image, and advertising, merchandising and sponsorship opportunities. Sponsorship benefits companies through increased sales and brand awareness, improved company image, corporate hospitality opportunities, and tax deductions.

Not all elite performers are equally marketable. Sponsors want performers who present a positive image and are at the top of their profession. Nike's decision to back the world number one golfer Rory McIlroy, rather than his compatriot Graeme McDowell, rested on his continued success, his clean-cut image, and golf's high socio-economic audience.

Sponsorship and the elite performer

Side by side

For the performer

Positive effects
Increased wages, prize money and extrinsic rewards; increased availability of full-time professional contracts; a higher public profile requiring appropriate behaviour; and increased funding for training support and equipment
Negative effects
Increased pressure to win and win-at-all-costs behaviour; deviant behaviour such as playing while injured or taking drugs; being treated as a commodity with overly demanding sponsors; and inequality of funding for minority sports
SponsorshipPositive effectsNegative effects
For the performerIncreased wages, prize money and extrinsic rewards; increased availability of full-time professional contracts; a higher public profile requiring appropriate behaviour; and increased funding for training support and equipmentIncreased pressure to win and win-at-all-costs behaviour; deviant behaviour such as playing while injured or taking drugs; being treated as a commodity with overly demanding sponsors; and inequality of funding for minority sports

The ethics of sport sponsorship

An elite performer such as the boxer Anthony Joshua has to consider the nature of a sponsor, because performers are role models with a social duty to others, and has to weigh how much control a sponsor will have.

Lock it in

  • •Weigh the social duty to others, whether personal appearances are demanded too much, and whether the product is opposed to the performer's reputation
  • •There may be a negative impact on future sponsorship, and support is image dependent
  • •The product may be opposed to the true nature of sport, and the performer is a role model for others

The opposite case is arguable too. Where a product is lawful, a performer is entitled to sign. Expecting them to take a stand puts their income on the line for a principle nobody else is being asked to fund. And being treated as a role model is something done to them, not something they volunteered for.

Effects on the sport as a whole

Commercialisation acts on the sport itself as well as on the people in it. The gains are mostly financial, and the costs are mostly about control, because money arriving from outside a sport tends to come with expectations about how that sport is run.

Side by side

For the sport itself

Positive effects
Funding pays for facilities, equipment, coaching and talent identification, and for the technology that helps officials reach correct decisions. More events and competitions are staged, more role models become visible to draw people into the sport, and spectator involvement grows through team kit and merchandise
Negative effects
A sport can become over-reliant on commercial income, and is left exposed if that funding is withdrawn. Traditional supporters often resist the new competitions, rule changes and altered formats that broadcasters and sponsors ask for
CommercialisationPositive effectsNegative effects
For the sport itselfFunding pays for facilities, equipment, coaching and talent identification, and for the technology that helps officials reach correct decisions. More events and competitions are staged, more role models become visible to draw people into the sport, and spectator involvement grows through team kit and merchandiseA sport can become over-reliant on commercial income, and is left exposed if that funding is withdrawn. Traditional supporters often resist the new competitions, rule changes and altered formats that broadcasters and sponsors ask for

Impact on coaches, officials and spectators

Side by side

Coaches and managers

What they gain
Higher profile and salaries, and increased funding for squads and facilities
What they face
Intense pressure to win, media demands, and inequalities between clubs

Officials

What they gain
Higher profile and salary, and access to training and technology
What they face
Increased pressure to get decisions right, media scrutiny, and the risk of demotion if a faulty decision is highlighted

Spectators

What they gain
Higher performance standards, improved facilities, and viewing technology such as Hawkeye
What they face
Increased costs, loss of traditional match features, more breaks in play, fewer tickets as more go to corporate hospitality, and less coverage of minority sports
GroupWhat they gainWhat they face
Coaches and managersHigher profile and salaries, and increased funding for squads and facilitiesIntense pressure to win, media demands, and inequalities between clubs
OfficialsHigher profile and salary, and access to training and technologyIncreased pressure to get decisions right, media scrutiny, and the risk of demotion if a faulty decision is highlighted
SpectatorsHigher performance standards, improved facilities, and viewing technology such as HawkeyeIncreased costs, loss of traditional match features, more breaks in play, fewer tickets as more go to corporate hospitality, and less coverage of minority sports

Lock it in

  • •Officials face over-dependency on technology, and faulty decisions being highlighted
  • •Increased media pressure, and constant analysis of decisions
  • •And a lack of technology at lower levels

Also study

Flashcards

29 cards ready

Practice questions

16 questions ready