FlashcardsNotesPractice QuestionsMy ProgressFriendsPast PapersLog in
FlashcardsNotesPractice QuestionsMy ProgressFriendsPast PapersLog in

AcePE is an independent student-made resource. Not affiliated with or endorsed by AQA.

About this siteSend feedbackPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service

← Ethics

Ethics

01

Ethics in Sport

Amateurism

Key term

Amateurism
Participation in sport purely for the love of it, with no financial gain, based on the idea of athleticism: physical endeavour combined with moral integrity. It developed as a code of sporting ethics among the upper and, later, middle classes during the Victorian era.

Elite sport was dominated by the upper and middle classes, who wrote the rules that formed the basis of many national governing bodies, the Football Association in 1863 among them. Amateurism was built around high moral values: fair play, sportsmanship, and immediate acceptance of the rules and of referee decisions. Training was frowned upon, because it suggested professionalism.

Traces remain in modern British sport. Fair play and sportsmanship are still promoted through football's Fair Play Awards and pre-match and post-match handshakes, and Rugby Union, which retained amateurism until late in the twentieth century, still refers to the referee as Sir.

The Olympic oath

Key term

Olympic oath
Written by Baron de Coubertin and first taken at the 1920 Antwerp Games. It is sworn at each Games' opening ceremony by one athlete, one judge committing to impartiality, and one coach, promising to compete respecting the rules, without doping, in the true spirit of sportsmanship.

Side by side

Evidence

The case for
The Olympics is still seen as a festival of fair play
The case against
Repeated doping scandals, including the Russian athletes banned from Rio 2016, and win-at-all-costs behaviour such as Philip Hindes admitting he deliberately crashed at London 2012 to trigger a restart
Is the oath still relevant?The case forThe case against
EvidenceThe Olympics is still seen as a festival of fair playRepeated doping scandals, including the Russian athletes banned from Rio 2016, and win-at-all-costs behaviour such as Philip Hindes admitting he deliberately crashed at London 2012 to trigger a restart

Sportsmanship

Key terms

Sportsmanship
Conforming to the written rules, spirit and etiquette of a sport, showing fairness, self-control and respect for opponents and officials. Footballers kicking the ball out for an injured opponent, or cricketers walking before being given out, are examples.
Simulation
Deceiving an official by over-acting, such as diving.

Sportsmanship is under pressure as winning becomes more important. Simulation is common, and so are breakdowns in etiquette, such as Suarez and Evra refusing to shake hands in 2012.

It can be encouraged through NGB campaigns such as the FA's Respect initiative, fair play awards such as UEFA's Fair Play Award, technology allowing correct decisions and the citing of missed offences, rule changes, on-field punishment such as sin-binning and sending off, post-event punishment, and rigorous drug testing.

Gamesmanship and the win ethic

Key terms

Gamesmanship
The art of winning by cunning means without technically breaking the rules: stretching rules to their limit and disregarding etiquette, by delaying a restart, time-wasting, verbal sledging, or deliberately deceiving an official.
Win ethic
A win-at-all-costs mentality in which coming second is not acceptable. Sometimes called the Lombardian ethic, after Vince Lombardi.

The 1981 underarm bowling incident is the famous example of gamesmanship. Australia's captain Greg Chappell instructed his brother Trevor to bowl the last ball underarm, making it impossible for New Zealand to win. It was legal at the time, and hugely controversial.

The win ethic produces more serious examples: rugby coaches faking injury with blood capsules to bring on a specialist kicker, and Diego Maradona's Hand of God at the 1986 World Cup. It shows up across elite sport in formats with no drawn games, managers being sacked after poor results, higher levels of deviant behaviour, and media coverage that praises winners while criticising losers.

Easy to get wrong

  • Common mistake: Gamesmanship is just another word for cheating.

    Correct version: Gamesmanship stays inside the written rules while ignoring their spirit. Breaking the rules outright is deviance.

Positive and negative deviance

Key terms

Deviance
Behaviour that goes against the accepted norms of society. In sport it takes both positive and negative forms.
Positive deviance
Over-adherence or over-conformity to sporting norms, such as training or competing while injured out of excessive commitment. Paula Radcliffe competing injured at the 2004 Athens Olympics is a well-known example.
Negative deviance
Under-conformity to norms, often driven by the pressure to win: taking illegal performance-enhancing drugs, deliberately fouling or harming an opponent, accepting a bribe to fix a match, or diving to win a penalty.

Lock it in

  • •Positive deviance is too much conformity, not good behaviour
  • •Negative deviance is too little conformity
  • •Both are deviance, because both depart from the accepted norm

Also study

Flashcards

34 cards ready

Practice questions

11 questions ready