FlashcardsNotesPractice QuestionsMy ProgressFriendsPast PapersLog in
FlashcardsNotesPractice QuestionsMy ProgressFriendsPast PapersLog in

AcePE is an independent student-made resource. Not affiliated with or endorsed by AQA.

About this siteSend feedbackPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service

← Influences on the Team

Influences on the Team

02

Group Dynamics

What makes a team a team

A team is more than a group of individuals. They have to work together to achieve a goal, and may have to perform different functions, such as attacker or defender, to make the team unit complete. Four characteristics mark one out.

Key terms

Collective identity
The team can be recognised easily, usually because they wear the same colour kit. Members often feel a strong affiliation and gain a sense of pride from wearing the team clothing, which gives motivation and a sense of belonging.
Interaction
Members should operate in their own role successfully and link that role with other members. In netball the defence and central players may each mark a specific opponent while communicating with each other to cover opposition attacks.
Communication
Individual players should talk to each other and communicate non-verbally in a way others understand, such as rugby players using a coded call or hand signal to indicate where the ball is being thrown at the line out.
A shared goal or purpose
The prospect of achieving success is what keeps players in the team and working for each other. All players should aim for the same goal for maximum motivation.

Tuckman's stages of group formation

How it works

  1. 1Forming: a short first stage where the group comes together and gets to know each other. Individuals work out how they feel about the team and whether they will fit in, assessing their own strengths and weaknesses against those of others in the group
  2. 2Storming: a stage of potential conflict, where individuals compete to establish position, status or role. Two players may be competing for the same position, and the coach or captain should resolve this as quickly as possible so players accept an alternative role
  3. 3Norming: once conflicts are resolved the team settles down and co-operates with the intention of achieving their goals. Group standards are accepted and cohesion develops
  4. 4Performing: all players are interactive and working together towards their goals. Team members support each other and understand their role

Tuckman set this out in 1965. How long the process takes varies with the size of the group, the difficulty of the task and the experience of the players. Established club teams can move through the stages quickly, while representative and international teams take longer, because players have to learn unfamiliar tactics and new roles in a limited time during infrequent meetings.

Task and social cohesion

Key terms

Cohesion
The tendency of members of a team to work together to achieve what they want to achieve. Psychologists debate whether cohesion causes success or success causes cohesion.
Co-action
Where others do the task at the same time but separately, as in rowing, where all the crew must literally pull together.
Interaction
Where each player has a different role that must be integrated with the roles of the other team members.
Task cohesion
Looks at the end result. Every player works together to achieve the goal, either by doing their own role well so others can make their contribution, or by working hard alongside everyone else on the task.
Social cohesion
Looks at the interaction of individuals in the team and how they work with each other: the degree of trust in each other's ability and the support given to each member. They may socialise together away from the game.

Side by side

What it gives the team

Social cohesion
Helps the team be interactive, and helps communication and team spirit
Task cohesion
Provides motivation, because all members work hard to win the cup or league title. The prize on offer becomes more important than any social differences

The risk

Social cohesion
Can be a negative influence, since it may produce sub-groups or cliques, meaning some members will not co-operate or contribute to team questions or tactics
Task cohesion
Without it, results would soon be poor
Social cohesionTask cohesion
What it gives the teamHelps the team be interactive, and helps communication and team spiritProvides motivation, because all members work hard to win the cup or league title. The prize on offer becomes more important than any social differences
The riskCan be a negative influence, since it may produce sub-groups or cliques, meaning some members will not co-operate or contribute to team questions or tacticsWithout it, results would soon be poor

Task cohesion is the more important of the two, and it can override the problems of social cohesion. A team's performance and results may still be good even if the players do not socialise together.

Carron's antecedents of cohesion

Key terms

Carron's antecedents
The four main influences on the cohesion of a team, identified by the psychologist Carron. They are the things that must be in place for cohesion to be effective.
Environmental factors
The size of the group and the time available. The larger the group, the more time they need to learn each other's roles, and the more chance there is of social loafing, the Ringelmann effect, and a sub-division or clique forming.
Personal factors
The similarity of group members in their aspirations, opinions and values, whether they are happy with the role they play, and how they act.
Leadership factors
The leadership style chosen by the coach or captain, and how well the captain or coach gets on with the others in the team.
Team factors
Team success, which raises cohesion the more of it is achieved. The team's experience of wins and losses matters, as does how long the team has been together. A threat from another group tends to bind the team together and eliminate internal disputes.

Steiner's model of team performance

Actual productivity = Potential productivity − Losses due to faulty processes

Steiner's 1972 model: having the best players does not guarantee the best results.

Key terms

Actual productivity
The performance of the team at a given time, at the end of the game: the result, the end outcome, a win, a loss or a draw.
Potential productivity
The team's best possible outcome if everything went perfectly during the game. It is affected by the skill level and ability of the players compared with their opponents, how difficult the task ahead is, and factors such as player ability and group resources.
Co-ordination problems
A type of faulty process: players fail to listen to the coach's instructions, employ the incorrect tactics, fail to communicate with each other, or misunderstand their role in the team.
Motivational problems
The other type of faulty process: players suffer from too much or too little arousal, or lose the drive to win, with a resulting reduction in effort and concentration.

Losses due to faulty processes are the things that go wrong to reduce group outcomes and prevent group potential being reached. The thinking behind the whole model is that the best players still have to be moulded by the coach into a cohesive unit, and kept motivated.

Social loafing and the Ringelmann effect

Key terms

Social loafing
A loss of motivation by an individual within the team, due to a lack of performance identification, meaning their efforts have not been recognised. Social loafers coast through the game and hide behind team members they think will cover for them, taking easy options and making a limited contribution.
Ringelmann effect
Described more than a century ago and still significant. A study of tug of war found individual effort within the group reduced as group size increased: individuals tried hard on the rope pull when their efforts were highlighted, but reduced their effort in a team of eight.

Social loafing can be caused by a lack of confidence, a negative attitude towards the position the player has been selected in, poor leadership from the coach or captain who fails to offer incentives and reinforcement, not understanding or accepting the role they need to play, lacking the fitness to maintain that role for a whole game, or goals set by the coach that are too general and lack meaning.

Easy to get wrong

  • Common mistake: Social loafing and the Ringelmann effect are the same thing.

    Correct version: Social loafing is a loss of motivation by an individual within the team. The Ringelmann effect is more collective: group performance decreases as group size increases.

Avoiding social loafing and promoting cohesion

The coach's job is to make sure players' efforts are recognised and rewarded. Giving players specific roles, such as responsibility for marking a particular opponent, and using statistics such as tackle counts, number of assists or pass completion rates, makes an individual contribution visible.

The fuller set of strategies for promoting cohesion, reducing social loafing and solving co-ordination problems: set individual and more challenging goals; involve all players in goal setting; give specific roles within the team and make sure each role is clear and accepted; promote motivation with rewards; establish a group identity; use statistics to highlight individual performance; use team meetings to resolve conflict; maintain communication with open discussion; and reward exceptional contribution to the team.

A coach might also use video analysis, a form of sports analytics, to highlight an individual's performance and use feedback to evaluate and assess it. In training, the aim is to avoid situations where social loafing could occur, and to vary practice to maintain motivation and conditioning.

Also study

Flashcards

52 cards ready

Practice questions

10 questions ready