FlashcardsNotesPractice QuestionsMy ProgressFriendsPast PapersLog in
FlashcardsNotesPractice QuestionsMy ProgressFriendsPast PapersLog in

AcePE is an independent student-made resource. Not affiliated with or endorsed by AQA.

About this siteSend feedbackPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service

← Skill Acquisition

Skill Acquisition

04

Use of Guidance & Feedback

Types and purposes of feedback

Key term

Feedback
Information received during or after a performance that is used to correct errors and improve future attempts.

Feedback is only useful when the type matches what the performer needs at that moment. The six types below are not alternatives to choose between once, but a set a coach draws from differently depending on the performer and the skill.

Key terms

Positive feedback
Informs the performer that their performance was good, encouraging and motivating them to continue performing the skill in the same way.
Negative feedback
Informs the performer that an error has occurred. It can feel unwelcome, but it is necessary so mistakes are identified and eliminated, particularly for more experienced performers.
Extrinsic feedback
Feedback from an outside source, such as a coach, a teammate, video or spectators. It can reinforce correct technique or highlight aspects the performer cannot detect themselves.
Intrinsic feedback
Feedback that comes from within the performer, using their own sense of movement, or kinaesthesis, and their internal feel for whether an action was correct.
Knowledge of results
Feedback about the outcome of an action, such as whether a shot scored or missed. It is available immediately at the end of an attempt.
Knowledge of performance
More detailed feedback about the technique and quality of the movement itself rather than just the outcome, used to help the performer produce a better performance next time.

Lock it in

  • •Six types: positive, negative, extrinsic, intrinsic, knowledge of results, knowledge of performance
  • •Extrinsic comes from outside, intrinsic comes from within
  • •Results is the outcome, performance is the technique

Matching feedback to the stage of learning

The type of feedback that works best changes as a performer moves through the stages of learning, because what shifts is how much the performer can judge for themselves.

Side by side

Cognitive stage

Feedback that works best
Extrinsic feedback combined with positive encouragement. Frequent, simple advice on both technique and outcome
Why
A novice lacks the experience to judge their own performance accurately, so this builds confidence and corrects early errors

Associative stage

Feedback that works best
More detailed feedback, with some of the performer's own intrinsic feedback used alongside the coach's extrinsic feedback
Why
The performer is beginning to detect errors themselves, which allows steady progress and refinement of technique

Autonomous stage

Feedback that works best
Mainly intrinsic feedback, using their own kinaesthetic sense
Why
The performer can make fine adjustments and self-correct, maintaining a high level of control over their performance
StageFeedback that works bestWhy
Cognitive stageExtrinsic feedback combined with positive encouragement. Frequent, simple advice on both technique and outcomeA novice lacks the experience to judge their own performance accurately, so this builds confidence and corrects early errors
Associative stageMore detailed feedback, with some of the performer's own intrinsic feedback used alongside the coach's extrinsic feedbackThe performer is beginning to detect errors themselves, which allows steady progress and refinement of technique
Autonomous stageMainly intrinsic feedback, using their own kinaesthetic senseThe performer can make fine adjustments and self-correct, maintaining a high level of control over their performance

Lock it in

  • •Feedback moves from extrinsic to intrinsic as the performer improves
  • •Beginners need it frequent, simple and positive
  • •Autonomous performers correct themselves by feel

Methods of guidance

Key terms

Visual guidance
A demonstration of the skill that gives the performer a mental image to copy, delivered live by a coach or peer, or through video, images or diagrams. Highly effective for beginners.
Verbal guidance
Spoken explanation of the task, often used together with visual guidance to draw attention to specific points of technique. Particularly useful for more advanced performers who can already picture the skill and need detailed or tactical advice.
Manual guidance
Physical support given by the coach to help the performer complete a movement, such as holding a gymnast through a new skill.
Mechanical guidance
The use of an artificial aid to support performance, such as a swimming armband or a trampoline harness.

Side by side

Visual

Strengths
Works best when the demonstration is accurate, at the correct speed, and repeated, so the performer builds a clear picture of what is required
Limitations
Inaccurate or overly complex demonstrations confuse the learner

Verbal

Strengths
Directs attention to specific technical points, and can carry detail and tactics that a demonstration cannot
Limitations
Too much information overloads and confuses the performer, and language that is too technical may not be understood by a beginner

Manual

Strengths
Builds confidence and can remove the fear of dangerous or difficult tasks
Limitations
Used for too long it creates over-reliance, preventing the performer from performing the skill unaided, and it can become physically intrusive

Mechanical

Strengths
Builds confidence and reduces the danger of a task, allowing an early feel for the skill
Limitations
Like manual guidance it risks over-reliance, and it can reduce motivation to complete the task independently
MethodStrengthsLimitations
VisualWorks best when the demonstration is accurate, at the correct speed, and repeated, so the performer builds a clear picture of what is requiredInaccurate or overly complex demonstrations confuse the learner
VerbalDirects attention to specific technical points, and can carry detail and tactics that a demonstration cannotToo much information overloads and confuses the performer, and language that is too technical may not be understood by a beginner
ManualBuilds confidence and can remove the fear of dangerous or difficult tasksUsed for too long it creates over-reliance, preventing the performer from performing the skill unaided, and it can become physically intrusive
MechanicalBuilds confidence and reduces the danger of a task, allowing an early feel for the skillLike manual guidance it risks over-reliance, and it can reduce motivation to complete the task independently

Easy to get wrong

  • Common mistake: Manual and mechanical guidance are the same thing.

    Correct version: Manual guidance is physical support from a person; mechanical guidance is support from an artificial aid. Both risk over-reliance, which is why they are easily confused.

Lock it in

  • •Visual for beginners, verbal for advanced performers
  • •Manual is a person, mechanical is a device
  • •Both physical methods build confidence but breed dependence if overused

Also study

Flashcards

42 cards ready

Practice questions

13 questions ready